The tile itself is awesome! We ordered 14 pieces and we were able to divide them into "light", "medium", and "dark". We are using this tile in a bathroom, so we can put 1 shade of the tile on each of the 3 walls, works great! We will have to use the tile with the big scratch behind the cabinet or toilet and use the tiles with visible chips in the locations where the tile needs to be cut down anyway. This product deserves a 5-star rating and the scratch and chipping is the only reason I demoted my rate to 4-stars.